The Miami Dolphins once believed they had struck gold when they committed a staggering $212 million to quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. He was supposed to be the franchise quarterback, the one to finally fill the shoes left vacant since the days of Dan Marino. But fast-forward to the present day, and the mood has soured — drastically.
What was once a bold vote of confidence in Tua has become a growing source of frustration. Fans are now taking to social media and talk radio with a blunt and increasingly common message: “We don’t need him anymore.”
From inconsistent play to doubts about his leadership in big games, the $212 million deal is being viewed as not just an overpay, but as a massive organizational misstep — one that could cost Miami dearly for years to come.
The Deal: What Did the Dolphins Sign Up For?
In early 2025, the Dolphins and Tua Tagovailoa finalized a five-year, $212 million extension. The deal included:
$150 million guaranteed
An average annual value of $42.4 million
Incentives tied to playoff performance and Pro Bowl selections
At the time, the deal placed Tua among the top-paid quarterbacks in the league — a position reserved for the likes of Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, and Josh Allen.
The Dolphins made their move after a 2023 season in which Tua led the league in passing yards and helped Miami finish with an 11–6 record. It looked like the natural next step.
But that was then. Now, everything has changed.
2024 Season Recap: Promise Crumbles Under Pressure
Tua’s performance in the 2024 season exposed the very cracks that critics had been warning about:
Too many turnovers in key moments
Struggles against elite defenses
Inconsistent deep-ball accuracy
Questions about durability, again
The Dolphins finished the season 9–8 and were eliminated in the Wild Card round in an embarrassing 34–10 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs. Tua threw three interceptions, fumbled once, and looked completely overwhelmed.
The result? Dolphins fans — long patient and hopeful — have begun to turn. And they’re turning hard.
Fan Reactions: “He’s a Flop. Cut Our Losses.”
Social media has been flooded with fans venting frustration:
🗣️ “We knew giving him that money was a mistake. We’re paying $200 million for mediocrity.”
🗣️ “Tua ain’t it. This contract haunts us now.”
🗣️ “He folds in big games. This isn’t the guy that leads you to a Super Bowl.”
🗣️ “We don’t need him anymore. Trade him, bench him — whatever. Just move on.”
The tone isn’t just disappointment — it’s betrayal. Many feel the front office rushed into locking down Tua without demanding playoff success first.
The Stats Don’t Lie — But They Don’t Win Rings Either
On paper, Tua’s stats don’t look terrible:
4,179 passing yards
27 touchdowns
14 interceptions
Completion rate: 66.8%
But here’s the problem — all his numbers collapse when the pressure is on. Against playoff teams, Tua had:
A 1–5 record
Just 8 touchdowns to 9 interceptions
A QBR below 60
In other words, when it matters most, he disappears.
Comparisons With Peers: The Gap is Obvious
Let’s compare Tua to other QBs in his pay range:
Quarterback Annual Salary 2024 Record Playoff Wins
Joe Burrow $55M 11–5 2
Patrick Mahomes $52.6M 12–5 3
Tua Tagovailoa $42.4M 9–8 0
Justin Herbert $52.5M 8–9 0
Not only is Tua falling short statistically — he’s failing where it counts: winning in January. And for a franchise star, that’s unforgivable in Miami’s current win-now window.
Cap Crunch: The Price of Faith
The Dolphins are now locked into Tua through 2029 unless they take a monstrous dead cap hit. Here’s the brutal financial outlook:
2025 cap hit: $38.2M
2026 cap hit: $46.5M
Dead cap if cut/traded in 2026: $78M
This deal has put Miami in a financial straitjacket, especially as they try to extend Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, both of whom have expressed frustration about the offensive stagnation.
Locker Room Concerns: Silent Tension
Reports have surfaced that not all is well inside the locker room. While Tua has never been openly criticized by teammates, subtle signs suggest growing discomfort:
Lack of postgame praise from receivers
Coaching staff refusing to commit long-term in pressers
Tua skipping voluntary workouts amid pressure
The worst-case scenario is playing out: a once-promising franchise QB now seen as a liability by fans, a burden on the cap, and a tension point in the locker room.
Front Office Under Fire
General Manager Chris Grier is now under enormous pressure. After several offseason misses and questionable draft picks, this Tua extension could define — and possibly end — his tenure.
Some insiders believe Miami may begin exploring QB competition options in the 2025 draft or even look into trade scenarios by 2026, despite the cost. The message is clear: If the Dolphins flop again next season, Tua could be gone — contract or not.
So What’s Next for Miami?
Here are the three possible paths ahead:
- Double Down on Tua
They give him a revamped offensive line, add another weapon, and hope 2025 finally clicks. Risky. - Draft a QB in 2025
Even a mid-round QB could be used to apply pressure and begin grooming a backup plan. - Shop Him Quietly
Explore trade options after June 1, 2026 — when the dead cap becomes more manageable. Could mean rebuilding.
Conclusion: “We Don’t Need Him Anymore” Isn’t Just Talk — It’s a Crisis
The $212 million extension meant to solidify Miami’s future has become an anchor dragging them down. Fans are furious, the team feels flat, and playoff hopes seem dimmer than ever.
What happens next will define the franchise for years — but one thing’s clear: if Tua can’t bounce back now, his days in Miami may be numbered, and his legacy might forever be marked by the label fans have already begun to use:
“Flop.”
—
Leave a Reply