In what was expected to be a fresh start and a defining moment for veteran tight end Jonnu Smith, the NFL trade talks that could have reignited his career have instead crumbled in dramatic fashion. Once viewed as a strategic piece on the move to a new offense, Smith’s name was trending across sports media — but not for the right reasons.
Now, what could have been a pivotal transition has turned into a source of controversy, confusion, and uncertainty as Smith finds himself stuck in limbo with no clear direction.
This article dives into how the trade talks surrounding Jonnu Smith broke down, the surrounding controversy that clouded the process, and what this means for the tight end’s future in the NFL.
Jonnu Smith: A Career in Need of Revival
Since entering the NFL in 2017 with the Tennessee Titans, Jonnu Smith has always been known for his combination of athleticism, speed, and physicality — a tight end capable of stretching the field and bruising defenders. His breakout seasons in Nashville earned him a lucrative four-year, $50 million contract with the New England Patriots in 2021.
However, Smith’s time in New England never quite lived up to the hype. Misuse in the offensive system, lack of consistent quarterback play, and injuries all played a role in his underwhelming performance. He tallied just 539 yards and 1 touchdown in two seasons before being traded to the Atlanta Falcons in 2023.
At first, the move to Atlanta showed promise. Reunited with Arthur Smith — the former Titans OC and now Falcons head coach — Jonnu found more rhythm, posting 582 yards and 3 touchdowns in the 2023 season. But the flashes of his potential weren’t enough to guarantee long-term security.
And then came the trade rumors.
A Promising Trade Takes Shape
According to league insiders, multiple teams — including the Los Angeles Chargers, Miami Dolphins, and Detroit Lions — expressed interest in trading for Jonnu Smith this offseason. The Chargers were believed to be the most aggressive, with new offensive coordinator Greg Roman looking to revamp the tight end-heavy schemes.
For Jonnu, a trade to Los Angeles would have meant a prime-time opportunity in a pass-first offense with Justin Herbert at the helm. His camp was reportedly “energized” by the rumors, and trade discussions progressed quickly.
As of late May, sources claimed the Falcons and Chargers had a tentative deal in place — a mid-round pick swap with performance-based incentives. It seemed all that was left was a final medical review and minor contract restructuring.
But then, things went sideways.
The Collapse: “Personality Conflicts” and Medical Red Flags
Reports emerged just days later that the trade had “fallen through.” At first, the narrative pointed to minor medical concerns, possibly tied to a nagging ankle injury Smith had been nursing during the 2024 season.
However, soon after, the story shifted. A controversial leak from an unnamed team official stated:
“The issue wasn’t just medical — there were concerns about personality clashes in the locker room and whether Jonnu would fully buy into a reduced role in a new system.”
This comment ignited a firestorm. Fans on social media debated whether Smith had attitude issues, while others defended him, pointing to his reputation as a hard-working professional with no prior disciplinary incidents.
Insiders close to Jonnu Smith quickly clapped back. One source stated:
“That’s a weak excuse. If personality was the problem, it should’ve been known before talks got serious. This was about money, plain and simple.”
The Controversy: Money, Miscommunication, or Mistrust?
Digging deeper, it’s now clear that contract structure played a key role in the collapse. Jonnu Smith was due $6.5 million in base salary for 2025 — a figure the Chargers wanted reduced or offset through incentives. Smith’s representatives reportedly pushed back, unwilling to restructure without guarantees of starting snaps or usage volume.
Meanwhile, the Falcons appeared reluctant to eat any portion of his salary if he was moved. With no compromise reached, the deal unraveled.
Then came the leak — a likely effort to deflect blame.
For many observers, the narrative was painfully familiar: a veteran player’s value being publicly diminished when trade talks fall apart. And for Jonnu Smith, the fallout has felt particularly harsh.
Jonnu Smith Responds: “I Don’t Quit on Myself”
Breaking his silence on the situation, Jonnu Smith posted a brief but telling message on Instagram:
“I’ve been doubted, cut, and counted out. Still here. Still grinding. I don’t quit on myself. Never have. Never will.”
He followed the post with a video of him training solo, wearing gear without any team logos — perhaps a symbolic statement of his status.
The post garnered support from fans, fellow NFL players, and even some media personalities who called out the way veterans are sometimes scapegoated in negotiations gone wrong.
What Now? Options and Uncertainty
With trade talks dead — at least for now — Jonnu Smith remains under contract with the Atlanta Falcons. But his role for the 2025 season is anything but clear.
The Falcons now feature Kyle Pitts, Bijan Robinson, and newly drafted TE prospect Malachi Boone, who is expected to take on hybrid H-back duties. Smith’s spot is not guaranteed.
Possible scenarios ahead include:
Post-June 1 Release: Cutting Smith after June 1 would save the Falcons cap space and open the door for him to explore options freely.
Reworked Trade: If another team suffers injuries during training camp or pre-season, Smith could become a more valuable asset.
Depth Role: He could stay in Atlanta as a TE2/3 option, although that might not satisfy his desire to be a featured contributor.
Conclusion: A Career in Flux, But Not Over
Jonnu Smith’s story is far from over. While this latest failed trade and the surrounding controversy have cast a shadow over his offseason, he’s shown resilience before — bouncing back from injury, scheme misfits, and skepticism.
The question now is not whether he can still play — his 2023 numbers proved he has gas in the tank. The question is: which team will believe in him next, and will they give him the role he deserves?
For now, Jonnu Smith remains one of the most intriguing veterans on the potential trade/free agent market — a player with talent, something to prove, and a fire that clearly hasn’t gone out.
Leave a Reply